And the not so good half (list still being worked on)--



Aliens of London / World War Three

Attack of the Cybermen

Battlefield

Boom Town

Carnival of Monsters

Colony in Space

Dalek

Delta and the Bannermen

Destiny of the Daleks

Earthshock

Enlightenment

Four to Doomsday

Frontios

Fury from the Deep

Galaxy 4

Ghost Light

Image of the Fendahl

Invasion of the Dinosaurs

Marco Polo

Meglos

Mindwarp

Paradise Towers

Planet of Fire

Planet of Giants

Planet of the Spiders

Resurrection of the Daleks

Revelation of the Daleks

Robot

Silver Nemesis

Snakedance

Survival

Terminus

Terror of the Vervoids

The Ambassadors of Death

The Androids of Tara

The Ark



The Armageddon Factor vs The Awakening



The Aztecs

The Celestial Toymaker

The Chase

The Creature from the Pit

The Curse of Fenric

The Daleks



The Daleks' Master Plan vs The Dæmons



The Dominators

The Edge of Destruction

The Enemy of the World

The Face of Evil

The Greatest Show in the Galaxy

The Gunfighters

The Happiness Patrol

The Horns of Nimon

The Ice Warriors

The Invasion of Time

The Keys of Marinus



The King's Demons vs The Krotons



The Long Game

The Mark of the Rani

The Massacre

The Mind of Evil

The Monster of Peladon

The Mutants



The Myth Makers vs The Pirate Planet



The Power of the Daleks

The Rescue

The Robots of Death

The Savages

The Seeds of Death

The Sensorites

The Smugglers

The Space Pirates

The Stones of Blood

The Tenth Planet

The Time Meddler

The Time Monster

The Twin Dilemma



The Two Doctors vs The Ultimate Foe



The Underwater Menace

The War Games

The War Machines

The Web Planet

Time and the Rani

Timelash

Warriors of the Deep

Warriors' Gate

Aliens of London / World War Three vs Attack of the Cybermen!

What a choice!

hmm, we doing the Good, the bad and the ugly are we??



I'll go for Attack of the Cybermen - a poor excuse for a story, which made no sense and added nothing to existing Cybermen lore.



An awful start to Season 22.

I'm not that much against Attack--they meant well, but it's not even Aliens of London material.



Battlefield vs Boom Town.

Battlefield is the worst of those.



That story had so much potential, but it got ruined by bad dialogue and over production.  A definite disappointment of the McCoy era.

As per Bad Wolf, Boom Town is one of the least liked Eccleston's. But still better than Battlefield!



Carnival of Monsters vs Colony in Space.



Dalek vs Delta and the Bannermen.

Colony In Space gets it.  I always found that story to be very slow and long winded, seemed very padded out.



Carnival had its flaws, but it was at least entertaining.



Delta and the Bannermen was simply awful, easily 'wins' this one! 



I would rather watch Dalek 10 times than see anything from Season 24!!!!

Carnival's excellent fun! Colony's main problem is the fact it's a six parter. Reverse the balance and it might be the other way...



Delta. Yep. 'Nuff said!



Destiny of the Daleks vs Earthshock.



Enlightenment vs Four to Doomsday.

Scrub Earhtshock from that; it's Destiny of the Daleks vs Dragonfire.

Dragonfire was appalling.  An awful story from an awful season.



Four to Doomsday is the weaker of the 2.  It seemed to have no purpose and long winded.  At 4 parts, it felt much longer.

I liked Dragonfire, it was the end of mel and the start of ace. and due to the constant bad reaction to 4 2 dooms day I have never seen it.

Two to one; Destiny over Dragonfire.



You've never seen Doomsday? Oh, well...Enlightenment wins...



Frontios vs Fury from the Deep.



Galaxy 4 vs Ghost Light.

I can't really comment on Fury From The Deep, as I havent seen it, so I'll go for Frontios.



Galaxy 4 definately is worse than Ghost Light.  From what Ive seen of Galaxy, it appeared to be drawn out and dull.



I hate to say this, but a lot of the very early 1st Dr stories, Im not a huge fan of.  Shocking I know!!!

I'd stick up for Galaxy, but I know Jimmy'll side with you. Ghost Light it is. Conversly, I will stick up for Fury 'cos I know he's a fan!



More Hartnell to come...



Image of the Fendahl vs Invasion of the Dinosaurs



Marco Polo vs Meglos.

Invasion of the Dinasours for sure!  That was a classic example of a story over-reaching itself.  It had some interesting concepts, but the production design let things down considerably.



Image of the Fendahl is a great story! - What's it doing on this list I ask?????



I'll go for Meglos - that story never quite gelled together as well as it should have.  A strangely forgettable one.

Sorry, that's you saying "Invasion of the Dinosuars wins the bas story award"?--'cos that's how I'm reading it! Image is here because it took on Inferno--ha! Meglos took on, Marco Polo however...



Mindwarp vs Paradise Towers



Planet of Fire vs Planet of Giants.

Yes, I meant Invasion of Dinasours gets the bad story vote.



Pardise Towers is simply awful, one of the most appalling stories in the Dr Who canon.  Towers gets the booby prize.





Planet of Giants also 'wins'.  I actually don't mind Planet of Fire, I think its a pretty campy story if you get into it the right way!!

Yep, yep--Paradise Towers? What where they thinking?



Planet of the Spiders vs Resurrection of the Daleks



Revelation of the Daleks vs Robot.

Planet of the Spiders I never liked.  Too drawn out and too many dull patches.  It was definately time for Pertwee to go at this point.



Robot was an ok opener, but fairly weak.  I think Revelation of the Daleks is a great story, definately one of the better Colin Baker ones.

Resurrection was very striking, but since Spiders is on Jimmy's good list you're outvoted.



Revelation had a huge scripting flaw as a two parter, and a huger one as a four parter. However I see Robot's on Jimmy's bad list, so no help there!



Silver Nemesis vs Snakedance.



Survival vs Terminus.