I'll go for the Time Meddler, as the episodes Ive seen of Tenth Planet weren't too bad at all. I thought the first version of the Cybermen were quite scary.
The Twin Dilemma gets the chop too. That was the worst first story for a Dr ever. So bad.
Martin
Posts: 840
Participation
Admin
offline
Subject: Re: The Bad Squash Table
24/05/2006 08:26 GMT
Time Meddler was pretty good,but up against the flawed Tenth Planet...! Twin Dillema, without a doubt!
The Underwater Menace vs The War Games.
The War Machines vs The Web Planet.
axelf
Posts: 444
Participation
offline
Subject: Re: The Bad Squash Table
24/05/2006 08:53 GMT
I'll have to go for the War Games, even though it closed off the 2nd Drs era.
That story was too long, and didnt really gather steam until the last 2 episodes.
The Underwater Menace at least looked interesting.
The Web Planet gets my vote. A classic example of how limited production values really spoiled a story. I found that one to be really dull.
Martin
Posts: 840
Participation
Admin
offline
Subject: Re: The Bad Squash Table
24/05/2006 09:45 GMT
OK--last four:
Time and the Rani vs Timelash.
Warriors of the Deep vs Warriors' Gate .
axelf
Posts: 444
Participation
offline
Subject: Re: The Bad Squash Table
24/05/2006 09:48 GMT
Timelash was awful, but I'd happily watch that than see Time and the Rani again!
Time and the Rani is without question, one of the very worst Dr Who stories ever. Put this at No.. 1 !!!!!
I find Warriors of the Deep to be quite funny really. Its one of those 'so bad its good' ones.
But I'll have to give that one the axe, as I like Warriors Gate, such an inventive story that one.
offline
